On October 23, 2026, 45 Highland Avenue in Piedmont closed at $6,000,000. It had been listed at $4,298,000. Ten months earlier, on December 3, 2025, 187 St James Drive closed at $1,575,000 against a list price of $1,950,000. The same town and the same multiple listing service produced those two results. The calendar accounts for most of the difference.
Buyers who have looked at Piedmont know the asking price is usually a starting point. The month-by-month record shows something more useful. For most of the year, a Piedmont list price is an opening bid. In the stretch that starts around Thanksgiving, it begins to behave like an actual price. Thanksgiving falls next Thursday, so that stretch is close.
Every October sale closed over list, two years running
The Piedmont Exedra publishes a monthly home sales report, a ledger drawn from bridgeMLS that lists each closed sale with its list and sale price. The latest edition runs through October 2026, so a full year of Piedmont closings can be laid side by side.
The ledger shows 13 sales in October 2026, and all 13 closed above list. By our math from the ledger, the median sale price that month was $2,850,000 and the median sale-to-list ratio was about 128%. The widest gaps came from 140 Indian Road, listed at $2,495,000 and sold for $4,300,000, and 15 La Salle Court, listed at $2,950,000 and sold for $4,100,000. Even the smallest overbid of the month, at 114 Indian Road, closed about 9% over list.
October 2025 looked much the same. It had 15 sales, every one above list, with a median sale-to-list ratio of about 119%. In fall 2026 the overbid grew larger than it was a year earlier. In both years, an October list price told a buyer where the bidding would start.
December 2025 is when the list price became the price
Two months after that October, the ledger changes. December 2025 had 12 closed sales. Six of them closed at or below list, and a seventh, 240 Wildwood Avenue, closed $5,000 over its $1,999,000 asking price. Three of those sales closed at exactly their list price: 21 Arroyo Avenue at $1,900,000, 1361 Oakland Avenue at $1,350,000 and 107 Monticello Avenue at $1,729,200. Two closed clearly under: 61 Wildwood Avenue at $2,250,000 against $2,398,000, and 187 St James Drive at about 81% of its asking price. The December median sale-to-list ratio comes out to roughly 100%.
January 2026 had only three sales. Two of them, 44 Farragut Avenue at $11,750,000 and 1850 Trestle Glen Road at $3,000,000, closed at list. By February, overbids were back. Nine sales closed that month with a median near 124% of list, and three of them, 1117 Ranleigh Way, 46 Manor Drive and 310 Magnolia Avenue, sold for more than 140% of asking.
The months side by side, with every ratio worked out from the ledger's list and sale prices:
| Closing month | Sales | Closed at or below list | Median sale-to-list |
|---|---|---|---|
| October 2025 | 15 | 0 | about 119% |
| November 2025 | 11 | 2 | about 124% |
| December 2025 | 12 | 6 | about 100% |
| January 2026 | 3 | 2 | about 100% |
| February 2026 | 9 | 2 | about 124% |
| April 2026 | 14 | 0 | about 129% |
| August 2026 | 10 | 3 | about 133% |
| October 2026 | 13 | 0 | about 128% |
The counts are small, as they always are in a town this size. The pattern still holds across the year. In April 2026 all 14 sales closed above list, with 224 Mountain Avenue going from $5,500,000 to $7,500,000. The months when the list price held were the quiet ones.
Fewer buyers, and fewer homes still for sale
The county and state numbers show the same seasonal slowdown, though in milder form. In the California Association of Realtors' December 2025 sales report, the median Alameda County home took 19 days to sell. In the March 2026 report, the figure was 12 days. C.A.R.'s statewide sale-to-list ratio fell to 97.9% in December 2025, then reached 100% in both March and April 2026. Piedmont moves over a much wider range than the state average. Its peaks are higher, and its December dip lands close to list instead of a couple of points below it.
The reason is practical. In Piedmont, buyer interest usually fades around Thanksgiving, and homes that have not sold by then are often taken off the market and relisted in spring. That shrinks both sides of the market at once, with fewer buyers bidding on fewer homes.
The fall market heading into this winter looked firm. C.A.R.'s September 2026 report put the Alameda County median at $1,265,000, up 1.2% from September 2025. Unsold inventory was 2.2 months, down from 2.4, and median time on market was 13 days, down from 16. Piedmont's October overbids were larger than the year before. That points to strong demand going into the holidays, and December 2025 shows that strong fall demand did not carry over to every house once Thanksgiving passed.
The same December still had bidding wars
A December list price was not a discount on every house. In December 2025, 64 Sharon Avenue closed at $5,896,000 against a $4,380,000 asking price. 1150 Oakland Avenue sold for $2,801,017 after listing at $1,995,000, and 235 Sunnyside Avenue went from $1,795,000 to $2,635,000. In November 2025, 2058 Oakland Avenue closed at $5,600,000 against $3,988,000, and 369 Hampton Road went from $1,598,000 to $2,410,000.
So winter changes the spread more than the level. In October, every result fell between modestly over list and far over list. In December, results ranged from 81% of asking to 147%. The town median says less in winter, and each listing has to be read on its own.
The top of the market had its own version of this. 26 Sea View Avenue listed at $15,000,000 and closed at $12,750,000 in November 2025. 83 Hazel Lane closed at its $5,500,000 list price the same month, and 44 Farragut Avenue closed at its $11,750,000 list price in January. Late summer showed something similar. Three of August 2026's ten sales closed below list, including 120 Somerset Road at $3,450,000 against $3,495,000 and 236 King Avenue at $2,792,000 against $2,900,000. When fewer buyers are looking, list prices hold less often, and the larger and higher-priced homes show it first.
Reading an asking price between now and February
For a buyer comparing Piedmont with Crocker Highlands or other Oakland neighborhoods this winter, the ledger has three practical lessons.
First, an October overbid ratio does not tell you what a December listing will sell for. A buyer who assumes 128% of list on a home still for sale in mid-December is using a figure from a busier market. Last December, half of the sales closed at or below what the seller asked.
Second, how long a house has been listed matters more in winter. A home that went on the market in early November and is still available after Thanksgiving faces the smaller pool of buyers still looking after Thanksgiving. A home listed fresh in the first weeks of the new year is aiming at the February market. Last February that market was back to a median near 124% of list.
Third, a single-family home in Piedmont changes hands only a few times a month. In January 2026 there were three sales in total. A buyer who wants a winter deal has very few houses to choose from and cannot wait for a second option at the same price. For a longer view of that tradeoff, see our post on why the quietest four months are often the most decisive.
Sellers can read the same table from their side. In both October 2025 and October 2026, every Piedmont sale closed above list. In December 2025, half did not. A seller who misses the fall window can either list into the thinner winter market or wait for February. Our home valuation page is the place to start if you are deciding between the two.
Questions buyers ask about winter in Piedmont
Does a winter purchase mean paying list price?
Not reliably. Last December's results ran from about 81% of asking at 187 St James Drive to about 147% at 235 Sunnyside Avenue. The median came out near list because the results fell on both sides of it, not because most homes sold at their asking price.
When does the spring-style overbid usually return?
In the 2025 to 2026 cycle, it came back in February. Nine sales closed that month at a median of about 124% of list, and none of March or April's sales closed below list.
Is Piedmont the only East Bay market that softens in December?
No. Alameda County days on market and the statewide sale-to-list ratio both eased in December 2025. Piedmont moved further because it starts from a much higher October overbid.
At Robert Jones, we track the Piedmont ledger address by address. If you plan to make an offer here between Thanksgiving and February, let's connect and look at how long that particular house has been listed and what comparable homes sold for in the same weeks last year.